Hiring Right the First Time…
Hiring is one of the highest-risk decisions a business can make. Get it right, and everything feels easier. Get it wrong, and the cost isn’t just financial… it seeps into culture, performance, morale, and leadership time.
Over the years, I’ve learned that “hiring right the first time” is about stacking the odds in your favour.
Below are the principles I consistently come back to when advising clients and making hiring decisions myself.
1. Cultural Fit Matters More Than Skills
In my experience, cultural fit matters more than skills and knowledge any day of the week. Skills can be taught. Cultural misalignment is far harder to fix… and a technically strong hire who doesn’t align with your values can damage a culture you’ve worked hard to build.
The challenge is that cultural fit isn’t easy to measure. There’s no test or scorecard. That’s why I recommend observing candidates across more than one environment: an informal coffee, a structured interview, time with the team, or a walk through the office. People often show different versions of themselves in different settings.
Pay attention to engagement, curiosity, respect and consistency. Small things matter… including how they treat people who aren’t part of the interview panel (i.e. the receptionsit). Gut feel isn’t quantifiable, but it’s powerful. If something feels off, listen to it.
2. Validate Knowledge with Scenario Assessments
Despite the emphasis on culture, knowledge and capability still matter… particularly in specialist roles.
Behavioural interview questions help, but they only go so far. Nothing validates experience like seeing how someone performs in a realistic scenario.
For example, with one architecture client, we provide a sample design brief with specific parameters and ask candidates to document their design concept.
This quickly reveals how they think, problem-solve and apply their technical skills. Anything that helps qualify the unknown reduces risk… especially when you consider the true cost of a bad hire.
3. Use Your Network, Not Just Referees
Normal reference checks have their place, but they’re inherently biased. Most candidates won’t list someone who will speak negatively about them… I can’t recall the last time I did a “bad reference check”.
If you know people who have worked with the candidate before, call them. Trusted insights from your network are often far more valuable than scripted references, provided the feedback comes from people whose judgement you respect.
4. Use Personality Profiling Tools
Personality profiling tools such as Hogan or Myers-Briggs can be incredibly insightful when used appropriately. They’re not about labelling people, but about understanding communication styles, motivators and potential cultural fit within a team.
Used as one data point… not a decision-maker – they can prevent costly misalignment.
5. Do Your Research
Finally, do your homework. Review professional profiles, check socials and look for consistency. You’re not looking to judge… you’re building a complete picture.
If a LinkedIn profile doesn’t match the resume… there’s a question to be asked.
Final Thought
A bad hire is expensive.
A great hire protects your culture and accelerates growth.
5. Do Your Research
Finally, do your homework. Review professional profiles, check socials and look for consistency. You’re not looking to judge… you’re building a complete picture.
If a LinkedIn profile doesn’t match the resume… there’s a question to be asked.
Final Thought
A bad hire is expensive.
A great hire protects your culture and accelerates growth.
You May Also Be Interested In…
Do You Own a Business… or Does It Own You?
If your business falls apart the moment you step away… you don’t own a business… you own a job.
Too many founders chase freedom, only to become trapped by the very thing they built. Here’s why it happens… and how to fix it.
How to Attract Top Talent Without a Big Budget
Over more than 20 years working in HR, employer branding and talent aquisition, I’ve learned that the organisations who hire the best people aren’t always the ones with the biggest budgets.